The whole argument
Who actually holds the pen once your own quote is written
You write the figure. On most claim-funded jobs, it isn't yours to finalise.
Written by the repairer$300–$15,000Adjusted
A real quote, priced against the panels, the paint and the hours the job actually needs.
The figure the insurer decides is fair, whether or not it matches the one you wrote.
Reviewed by the insurer The industry's own national code states plainly who that choice is left to, not shared across the trade:
The national Motor Vehicle Insurance and Repair Industry Code of Conduct defines a 'Choice of Repairer Policy' as each insurer's own policy terms on whether a customer gets any say over who repairs their car, and explicitly lists 'compulsory choice of Repairer' among the matters the Code itself does not require industry-wide - leaving the question to each insurer's own product disclosure statement, not to a shared rule.
Confirmed directly against Motor Vehicle Insurance and Repair Industry Code of Conduct, a voluntary national code developed following the Australian Government's Smash Repair and Insurance Industry Implementation Taskforce, not a government regulator or primary legislation's own published text. Verified 2 September 2026.
A driver's own consumer guidance states the same gap from the other side of the claim:
Financial Rights Legal Centre's own consumer factsheet on car insurance claims states that most policies give the insurer, not the policyholder, the right to decide whether a damaged car is repaired, cashed out, or written off, and that even a policy allowing the customer to nominate a repairer can still leave the insurer able to decide how repairs are carried out or to adjust the repairer's quote.
Confirmed directly against Financial Rights Legal Centre, a community legal centre specialising in financial services and insurance disputes, not a government body's own published guidance. Verified 2 September 2026.
None of this holds on every job. A cash repair paid straight by the customer never touches an insurer at all, and "most policies" isn't "all policies": some genuinely leave the choice, and the figure, with the driver. The code itself is an industry-agreed document, not legislation, drafted by the industry rather than handed down by a government regulator. What doesn't change on the jobs that do run through a claim is who holds the pen last, and on most of them it isn't the repairer who wrote the first number. That's the gap this page is actually built around, not a claim that every job in this trade works this way.